The Pros and Cons of Self-Insuring Long-Term Care
Thinking about the potential impact of long-term care often involves considering whether to buy long-term care (LTC) insurance or to self-insure. Sometimes your options are limited. For example, poor health or old age may make the cost of LTC insurance too expensive for you, or you may be denied coverage altogether. Medicaid may not be an alternative either if your income and assets exceed minimum qualification limits. In this case, self-insuring may be your only option. But if you are able to choose between LTC insurance and self-insuring, here are some issues to consider.
Why might you self-insure?
There are many reasons why people choose to self-insure rather than buy LTC insurance, presuming these options are available. Often, people will choose to self-insure because they think they have enough income and assets to pay for whatever long-term care they'll need, or they decide not to plan for long-term care because they think they'll never need it during their lives. However, there are both advantages and disadvantages to self-insuring.
Advantages of self-insuring
You have greater flexibility in how you use your financial resources. Even if you choose to allocate income or savings to potential long-term care costs by self-insuring, those assets will still be available to use for other purposes such as retirement, business ventures, or education funding.
Long-term care insurance premiums may become too expensive. Often, people buy LTC insurance during their working years, but find that their income decreases in retirement or policy premiums increase, making LTC insurance hard to pay for. If you own LTC insurance, or you're thinking about buying it, try to estimate what your income will be in retirement and whether you'll be able to afford the premiums, especially if they increase. If you think the premiums might be too costly, as an alternative, consider setting up an LTC savings account into which you can contribute as much as you can afford. This account may not provide the funds that an LTC policy could, but it can help pay for LTC expenses if they occur, and you won't be financially strapped with premium payments you can't afford.
You have more control over your care. Many policies provide only limited benefits--often with additional restrictions and conditions--that may end up covering only a small percentage, or even none, of your long-term care costs. For example, a policy may provide limited benefits for in-home care, even though most people would prefer to receive care at home. If you do need long-term care, using your own assets may give you more control over the type of care you get, where you receive the care, and who provides the care to you, without the restrictions or limits of some LTC insurance policies.
Disadvantages of self-insuring
If you never need long-term care, then, in hindsight, self-insuring is almost always the right choice. But what if you do need long-term care? How long will you need that care and how much will it cost? These uncertainties lead to some of the disadvantages of self-insuring.
Long-term care expenses can deplete your assets and income, leaving little or nothing for your spouse or dependents. Paying for some of your care with LTC insurance may allow you to conserve more of your savings and income for your spouse or dependents.
You may need to depend on family members to provide your care. Some people gamble that they'll never incur long-term care expenses. If they're wrong, their options may be very limited. If they can't qualify for Medicaid, their assets and income may be enough to pay for some of the care, but not all of it. Consequently, they often rely on family to provide some if not most of their long-term care. Long-term care insurance may cover some of the costs of skilled or custodial services and nursing home care, relieving your family of some of these caregiving responsibilities.
Self-insuring could increase your taxes. Depending on the type of assets you have, paying for long-term care from your savings could increase your income taxes. Withdrawals from certain retirement plans such as IRAs or 401(k)s are usually subject to ordinary income taxes, so taking sizable withdrawals from them to pay for long-term care expenses might increase your income taxes significantly. On the other hand, if your LTC insurance is tax qualified (as most policies are), then benefits paid from the policy for care are generally not subject to income taxes.






An HSA is a tax-favored account that can be opened in conjunction with a high-deductible health plan (HDHP) to pay for current health costs and save for future ones. The HSA/HDHP option may be attractive to healthy retirees under age 65 who want more flexibility and potentially lower health insurance premiums than traditional individual health insurance offers.
Reaching age 65 gives you a little more flexibility when it comes to using your HSA funds, since at age 65 the 10% penalty on nonqualified withdrawals no longer applies. But before you use your account funds for something other than health-care expenses, keep in mind that you'll still owe income taxes on money used for nonqualified expenses.
Are health insurance premiums taking too big of a bite out of your budget? Do you wish you had better control over how you spend your health-care dollars? If so, you may be interested in an alternative to traditional health insurance called a health savings account (HSA).
If a disabling illness or injury were to prevent you from working for weeks, months, or even years, how would you support yourself and your family? If disability strikes, you may discover that your most valuable asset isn't your home or your savings--it's your ability to earn a living. Fortunately, group disability insurance can help protect you. Whether it's offered through your employer, school, trade group, or another association to which you belong, group disability insurance is an affordable solution to your need for income protection.
Skilled care: Generally round-the- clock care that's given by professional health care providers such as nurses, therapists, or aides under a doctor's supervision.